Gd morning and Greetings !
Understanding banking system and pain areas in banking system
Understanding bank balance sheet ....
Liabilities section:
10 percent capital
90 percent borrowings in form of deposit
If any bank have 10 per cent NPA than entire capital of bank is lost as in case of most of nationalised banks
Above is the reason to believe not to buy any nationalised bank shares
Types of bank :
Banks can be broadly classified into
Nationalised ,Private , MNC and cooperative banks .
Pain areas in respective banks
A) Cooperative banks
PROBLEM:
They are Governed by Cooperative societies act 1965 and in 1966 Banking regulation act 1949 is Amended to bring cooperative banks under control of RBI for banking related transactions but for management the control vests with respective state govt s and for inspection NABARD is assigned the responsibility
So there are so many goal keepers and nobody take onus of goal as everybody think that other could have stopped it
CONCLUSION:
NIL cooperative banks were rescued in past inspite of so many failures apart of DIGC guarantee of 1 Lacs which were paid to deposit holders
There were 18 cooperative banks failed in 2017-18 and 43 crores was paid by DIGC and no bank was rescued
RESOLUTION:
Bring under direct control of RBI as other schedule Pvt sector banks
B) Schedule Commercial Private sector banks
PROBLEM :
Control of Single person in banks and that single person is so flambuyont that board in Pvt sector banks are dead and they are just rubber stamps
So decision is done by single person who is so politically connected and they have such big marketing budgets that they bag best bankers award by RBI and Media
Just to quote with example RBI has capitulated against Kotak Mahindra Bank rather than bank to capitulate against regulator in decision to postpone time to dilute stake of Uday Kotak in Kotak Mahindra bank .
Esteemed and respected people and top shot people in Pvt sector banks are so close to govt and so influenced that their board members have nothing to say in any bank decisions
That's the reason syphoning of funds in ICICI bank and yes bank might have happened
Best part is all private sector banks which are schedule commercial banks are rescued
Eg Bank of Rajathan was merged with ICICI and global trust bank with OBC and Bank of Punjab with Csnturion bank and later to HDFC bank in past
Only impact goes to shareholders and bond holders of Tier 1capital which is just 10 per cent of total bank balance sheet as 90 per cent is depositor money and that 10 percent shareholder value is repaired later post new bank acquiring it .
CONCLUSION:
ALL DEPOSITORS IN SCHEDULE COMMERCIAL PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS ARE SAFE AS IS CASE GLOBALLY AS ALSO IT IS DIRECT RESPONSIBILTY OF CENTRE GOVT WHO IS CONRROLLING RBI TO RUN BANKS UNLIKE COPERATIVE BANKS WHICH ARE NEVER RESCUED IN THE PAST
RESOLUTION:
Remove the dominance of single person by diluting stake and bringing in independent and stricter and hard regulator
C) Nationalised banks
PROBLEM:
Management is controlled by GOVT and Chairman is political post for any nationalised bank..
Govt cannot run business and running a commercial bank is a business .
That is the reason of fall in market caps of all public sector banks
Few examples to quote
SBI market cap is 2.57 lac crore
HDFC bank is 6.31 lac crore
ICICI market cap is 2.27 lac crore
Kotak bank is 3.17 lac crore
Axis bank market cap is 1.91 lac crore
Bandhan bank mkt cap is 68000 crore market cap is
AU market cap is close to 36 thousand crore
All nationalised banks merged together along with PNB and SBI there market cap is less than HDFC Bank
inspite of capitalisation on regular basis by GOVT of India in every interim and regular budget
Above state that nationalised banks are basic deflators to GDP in Indian economy
All nationalised banks specially SBI is from British times and long vintage but all Pvt banks are newly formed but still mkt cap is higher than nationalised banks
Crisis in this bank is considered if NPA goes beyond 10 per cent whereas in Pvt sector banks crisis is considered if NPA s goes beyond 3 percent
10 percent NPA means actually you are eating the entire share holding capital of bank which explained as above
CONCLUSION :
Nationalised banks merger will not do anything but privitising the banks will actually help and bringing stricter regulator on Pvt sector banks would help the economy
In recent fiasco of yes bank Faced the same problem as syphoning of funds company indirectly via lending to DHL might have happen for which the raids are going on and board kept silent throught out as discussed above and this might be similar suitation like ICICI bank with Chanda Kochhar fiasco
Money in yes bank is again safe as was in past as explained above as it is schedule commercial bank direct control under RBI and direct responsibility of RBI
RESOLUTION:
Bring Pvt management with less or no intervention on Central or state govt
Briefing the above narration in question form
Why can't govt capitalise depositors of cooperative banks ?
Why they play pass on games in case of Cooperative banks ?
Why can't cooperative banks be sole responsibility of RBI like other schedule commercial banks ?
Why Cant they bring strict regulator to minimise the impact of single person in Pvt sector banks ?
Why can't govt focus of social measures and leave business of running banks and continue loosing GDP ?
Why can't govt capitalise beforehand ILFS and DHL and avoid ripple effect rather than capitalising nationaljse bank due to poor Mgt ?
Why Nationalised banks require mergers ?
Why Nationalised banks can't be privatised ?
Why govt wants to keep control in nationalised banks and thereby help big businesses like Adani and Relaince of the world ?
Why depositors money is safe only in schedule Pvt sector banks and nationalised banks and not in cooperative banks ?
All these questions asked will make you understand what I am trying to narrate in this article
Regards
Amit Aggarwal
Disclaimer : just my own personal views and numerical data may be an approximation but idea is just to bring correct picture to depositors as so many customers asked me questions being a banker
Understanding banking system and pain areas in banking system
Understanding bank balance sheet ....
Liabilities section:
10 percent capital
90 percent borrowings in form of deposit
If any bank have 10 per cent NPA than entire capital of bank is lost as in case of most of nationalised banks
Above is the reason to believe not to buy any nationalised bank shares
Types of bank :
Banks can be broadly classified into
Nationalised ,Private , MNC and cooperative banks .
Pain areas in respective banks
A) Cooperative banks
PROBLEM:
They are Governed by Cooperative societies act 1965 and in 1966 Banking regulation act 1949 is Amended to bring cooperative banks under control of RBI for banking related transactions but for management the control vests with respective state govt s and for inspection NABARD is assigned the responsibility
So there are so many goal keepers and nobody take onus of goal as everybody think that other could have stopped it
CONCLUSION:
NIL cooperative banks were rescued in past inspite of so many failures apart of DIGC guarantee of 1 Lacs which were paid to deposit holders
There were 18 cooperative banks failed in 2017-18 and 43 crores was paid by DIGC and no bank was rescued
RESOLUTION:
Bring under direct control of RBI as other schedule Pvt sector banks
B) Schedule Commercial Private sector banks
PROBLEM :
Control of Single person in banks and that single person is so flambuyont that board in Pvt sector banks are dead and they are just rubber stamps
So decision is done by single person who is so politically connected and they have such big marketing budgets that they bag best bankers award by RBI and Media
Just to quote with example RBI has capitulated against Kotak Mahindra Bank rather than bank to capitulate against regulator in decision to postpone time to dilute stake of Uday Kotak in Kotak Mahindra bank .
Esteemed and respected people and top shot people in Pvt sector banks are so close to govt and so influenced that their board members have nothing to say in any bank decisions
That's the reason syphoning of funds in ICICI bank and yes bank might have happened
Best part is all private sector banks which are schedule commercial banks are rescued
Eg Bank of Rajathan was merged with ICICI and global trust bank with OBC and Bank of Punjab with Csnturion bank and later to HDFC bank in past
Only impact goes to shareholders and bond holders of Tier 1capital which is just 10 per cent of total bank balance sheet as 90 per cent is depositor money and that 10 percent shareholder value is repaired later post new bank acquiring it .
CONCLUSION:
ALL DEPOSITORS IN SCHEDULE COMMERCIAL PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS ARE SAFE AS IS CASE GLOBALLY AS ALSO IT IS DIRECT RESPONSIBILTY OF CENTRE GOVT WHO IS CONRROLLING RBI TO RUN BANKS UNLIKE COPERATIVE BANKS WHICH ARE NEVER RESCUED IN THE PAST
RESOLUTION:
Remove the dominance of single person by diluting stake and bringing in independent and stricter and hard regulator
C) Nationalised banks
PROBLEM:
Management is controlled by GOVT and Chairman is political post for any nationalised bank..
Govt cannot run business and running a commercial bank is a business .
That is the reason of fall in market caps of all public sector banks
Few examples to quote
SBI market cap is 2.57 lac crore
HDFC bank is 6.31 lac crore
ICICI market cap is 2.27 lac crore
Kotak bank is 3.17 lac crore
Axis bank market cap is 1.91 lac crore
Bandhan bank mkt cap is 68000 crore market cap is
AU market cap is close to 36 thousand crore
All nationalised banks merged together along with PNB and SBI there market cap is less than HDFC Bank
inspite of capitalisation on regular basis by GOVT of India in every interim and regular budget
Above state that nationalised banks are basic deflators to GDP in Indian economy
All nationalised banks specially SBI is from British times and long vintage but all Pvt banks are newly formed but still mkt cap is higher than nationalised banks
Crisis in this bank is considered if NPA goes beyond 10 per cent whereas in Pvt sector banks crisis is considered if NPA s goes beyond 3 percent
10 percent NPA means actually you are eating the entire share holding capital of bank which explained as above
CONCLUSION :
Nationalised banks merger will not do anything but privitising the banks will actually help and bringing stricter regulator on Pvt sector banks would help the economy
In recent fiasco of yes bank Faced the same problem as syphoning of funds company indirectly via lending to DHL might have happen for which the raids are going on and board kept silent throught out as discussed above and this might be similar suitation like ICICI bank with Chanda Kochhar fiasco
Money in yes bank is again safe as was in past as explained above as it is schedule commercial bank direct control under RBI and direct responsibility of RBI
RESOLUTION:
Bring Pvt management with less or no intervention on Central or state govt
Briefing the above narration in question form
Why can't govt capitalise depositors of cooperative banks ?
Why they play pass on games in case of Cooperative banks ?
Why can't cooperative banks be sole responsibility of RBI like other schedule commercial banks ?
Why Cant they bring strict regulator to minimise the impact of single person in Pvt sector banks ?
Why can't govt focus of social measures and leave business of running banks and continue loosing GDP ?
Why can't govt capitalise beforehand ILFS and DHL and avoid ripple effect rather than capitalising nationaljse bank due to poor Mgt ?
Why Nationalised banks require mergers ?
Why Nationalised banks can't be privatised ?
Why govt wants to keep control in nationalised banks and thereby help big businesses like Adani and Relaince of the world ?
Why depositors money is safe only in schedule Pvt sector banks and nationalised banks and not in cooperative banks ?
All these questions asked will make you understand what I am trying to narrate in this article
Regards
Amit Aggarwal
Disclaimer : just my own personal views and numerical data may be an approximation but idea is just to bring correct picture to depositors as so many customers asked me questions being a banker
Nice artivle
ReplyDelete